Washington, D.C., January 23, 2025
Pride Puppy is among the disputed books. Photo: goodreads.com
The U.S. Supreme Court agreed Friday to consider whether Maryland’s largest school district violated religious rights by requiring students to participate in lessons featuring LGBTQ-themed storybooks. Among the challengers is Svitlana Roman, a Ukrainian Orthodox Christian mother, alongside Roman Catholic and Muslim parents who object to their elementary school children being exposed to such material.
The dispute arose after Montgomery County Public Schools introduced books like Pride Puppy, about a dog lost at a Pride parade, Jacob’s Room to Choose, which features transgender school-aged children, My Rainbow, about a transgender child with autism, and others. When parents requested to opt their children out of these lessons, the district initially tried to accommodate them but later banned all opt-outs “for any reason,” reports CBS News.
“Under the Fourth Circuit’s reasoning, parents cannot be heard until after the damage has been done to their children. But there is no unringing that bell—by then, innocence will be lost and beliefs undermined,” the parents argued in their appeal.
The school board maintains that the books “impart critical reading skills through engaging, age-appropriate stories” and follows a careful selection process. They argue that allowing opt-outs raised concerns about student absenteeism and risked stigmatizing students whose families were represented in the books.
The case reached the Supreme Court after lower courts sided with the school district. The 4th Circuit Court found no evidence that families were compelled to change their religious beliefs or conduct. The school board argues that parents who choose public education can’t claim religious freedom violations simply because their children encounter materials they find offensive.
The case, which involves three sets of parents, could be heard either this summer or in the Court’s next term beginning October.
Follow OrthoChristian on Twitter, Vkontakte, Telegram, WhatsApp, MeWe, and Gab!